Pin it
Biting into a well-made Reuben sandwich hits all the right comfort spots. When the soft corned beef meets the zingy sauerkraut, gooey Swiss cheese, and rich thousand island dressing between two crunchy slices of rye bread, you get an amazing mix of tastes that's been winning fans since it first showed up in NYC.
When I whip these up during family get-togethers, they're gone in seconds. Just the aroma of rye bread toasting in butter always brings everyone running to the kitchen.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Seeded Rye Bread: Go for hearty, new loaves with visible seeds; they'll handle the stuffing better
- Corned Beef: Ask for fresh-cut at the deli, not too thin or thick
- Sauerkraut: The chilled kinds offer better crunch and tang
- Swiss Cheese: Grate it yourself for smoother melting
- Thousand Island Dressing: DIY or premium bought versions both do the trick
- Butter: Pick unsalted to manage the sandwich's saltiness yourself
Step-By-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1: Putting It Together
- - Use ingredients that aren't cold from the fridge
- Stack everything like this: bread first, then cheese, dressing, corned beef, sauerkraut
- Push down lightly to pack it all without crushing
- Spread butter smoothly across both outer bread sides - Step 2: Grilling Done Right
- - Warm your pan to medium heat, never cranked up high
- Set the sandwich down butter-side first
- Use a spatula to apply gentle pressure for better browning
- Wait until it turns golden (roughly 3 minutes each side)
- Turn it over carefully so everything stays in place
My grandma always loaded up her Reubens with extra sauerkraut. She talked about its tummy-friendly benefits and loved telling us how her mom fermented cabbage in wooden tubs at home.
Getting The Heat Just Right
Nailing the Reuben comes down to watching your cooking temperature. If it's too hot, your bread will turn black before your cheese goes soft. Too low, and you'll end up with wet, floppy bread. I've learned that keeping it at medium lets the cheese get perfectly melty while your bread turns that beautiful golden color.
Keeping It Fresh and Planning Ahead
Reubens taste best right after cooking, but you can get things ready beforehand. Keep all your stuff separate in the fridge, but don't forget to let the corned beef warm up a bit before making your sandwich. This tiny trick really makes the whole thing taste better.
Twists and Personal Touches
The original Reuben tastes great as it is, but feel free to switch things up. You might like using pastrami instead of corned beef for more smoky flavor, or trying different mustards with your thousand island dressing. Some folks tell me they love making it with turkey for something lighter, though the sandwich purists might say that's not really a Reuben anymore.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the top bread choice for a Reuben?
- Rye bread, whether dark or regular, gives both taste and support for the fillings.
- → Can I swap corned beef for pastrami?
- Definitely! Pastrami is a tasty alternative that works perfectly.
- → How do I stop my Reuben from being soggy?
- Dry the sauerkraut well before adding it and make sure to toast the bread fully.
- → What’s the cheese to use for Reuben sandwiches?
- Swiss cheese is the go-to—it melts great and has a creamy but mild flavor.
- → Can I make this sandwich ahead of time?
- For the best taste, toast it fresh. Just keep the ingredients separate if prepping early.