Pin it
A mouthwatering Italian-inspired grilled sandwich that blends delicate prosciutto with silky melted cheeses and fragrant basil. This dish turns simple components into something truly unforgettable, making it Stanley Tucci's favorite comfort meal that's both classy and deeply fulfilling.
When I first whipped up this sandwich, the mix of toasty sourdough and slowly melting mozzarella filled my kitchen with such amazing smells that everyone came running. The secret was taking it slow, letting the cheese get all gooey while the bread turned gorgeously golden.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Sourdough bread: Go for a sturdy loaf with good chew. Bread from yesterday works great
- Fresh mozzarella: Grab those soft, white balls stored in liquid. For extra richness, try buffalo mozzarella
- Aged cheese: Pick a bold provolone or aged gruyere to add complexity
- Prosciutto: Ask for paper-thin slices with good marbling at your deli
- Fresh basil: Select vibrant, perky leaves without browning
- Butter: Grab unsalted and let it soften before using
- Fresh pesto: Whip up your own or buy from the refrigerated section for best taste
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1:
- Get Everything Ready: Cut bread into medium slices. Make sure butter's soft enough to spread. Blot moisture from mozzarella with paper towels. Gather all your stuff before beginning. Warm your pan gradually to medium heat.
- Step 2:
- Stack Your Ingredients: Spread butter on the outer sides of bread. Start with shredded cheese on the inside for better melting. Arrange prosciutto in gentle waves. Scatter torn mozzarella bits evenly across. Dab pesto carefully around. Top with fresh basil.
- Step 3:
- Master Your Cooking: Drop sandwich into warm pan. Push down lightly with a spatula. Keep an eye on the heat. You want to hear a soft sizzle. Turn over once it's golden underneath. Cover with a lid briefly if needed to help cheese melt.
Pin it
I found that putting a lid on the sandwich during the final minute of cooking helps the cheese melt perfectly without burning the bread. This little trick changes a good sandwich into something truly special.
Ways to Make It Your Own
What's great about this sandwich is how flexible it is: Try different bread types. Swap in other Italian cold cuts. Mix up your cheese blend. Throw in some roasted red peppers. Add a few sundried tomatoes for extra punch.
Keeping It Fresh
Though it tastes best right away, you can: Get components ready beforehand. Keep cheese shredded in a container. Slice bread and store it. Prepare extra pesto to use later.
What to Serve With It
This sandwich goes great with: A simple arugula side salad. Classic tomato soup. A bowl of fancy olives. Italian pickled veggies.
I've made this sandwich my go-to quick meal for both laid-back lunches and fancy light suppers. It shows how good stuff cooked with care can turn even the simplest food into something you'll always remember.
Cooking Lessons Beyond
The tricks that make this sandwich amazing can help with other Italian dishes too. Getting how flavors work together – salty prosciutto balancing creamy cheese, fresh herbs cutting through richness – helps you cook better no matter what you're making.
Drinks and Sides That Work
To round out your meal: Crisp white wines like Pinot Grigio. Fizzy water with a lemon wedge. Some seasonal fresh fruit like ripe figs. Small-batch potato chips. A handful of mixed greens.
Ideas for Guests
This sandwich shines when company comes: Slice into bite-sized pieces for snacking. Set up a build-your-own sandwich station. Cook several at once for casual get-togethers. Put them next to an antipasto spread. Pack them for outdoor eating.
Changes Through the Year
Switch things up as seasons change: Spring - Toss in some tender microgreens. Summer - Layer in juicy tomato slices. Fall - Switch basil for sage leaves. Winter - Mix in some roasted garlic spread.
Pin it
This sandwich might seem basic, but it really captures what Italian cooking is all about - good ingredients, careful handling, and honoring tradition while adding your own touch. It reminds us that sometimes the most basic combos create the most satisfying bites.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which type of bread works best?
- Go for sourdough or a crusty bread that holds up and crisps well on the pan.
- → Can I skip making my own pesto?
- Totally. A good store-bought pesto does the trick, even if homemade is awesome.
- → Why do I need two cheeses?
- Mozzarella gives it that creamy pull while grated cheese boosts melt and flavor.
- → Can this be prepped in advance?
- Nope, it's at its best right off the griddle, when crispy and warm.
- → Any ideas for a side dish?
- Pair it with a fresh salad or a warm bowl of tomato soup. Both are perfect!