Pin it
Turn everyday items into a fancy sandwich treat, mixing crunchy garlic bread with juicy seasoned chicken and a perfect mix of gooey cheeses. This upgraded sandwich brings restaurant-worthy taste straight to your home.
After trying tons of sandwich combos in my kitchen, this mix has become what my family asks for most. The secret is spending time on each part - from well-seasoned chicken to perfectly crispy garlic bread.
Key Ingredients:
- Bread: Go for sourdough or Italian loaf, cut 1-inch thick for better support
- Chicken: Use boneless, skinless thighs or breasts for better flavor soaking
- Mozzarella: Pick whole milk fresh type for better stretchiness and melting
- Cheddar: Get the sharp kind for richer taste
- Parmesan: Grate it fresh, skip the pre-packaged stuff
- Garlic: Use fresh bulbs, finely chopped for stronger taste
- Butter: Try European style with extra fat content
- Mayo: Full-fat type makes the best base for spreading
- Mustard: Whole grain Dijon adds nice texture and tang
- Fresh herbs: Basil and Italian parsley work wonderfully together
Cooking Steps:
- Getting Chicken Ready:
- Add lots of salt, black pepper, and garlic powder to chicken breasts. Heat olive oil in big pan over medium-high until it shimmers. Cook chicken about 6-7 minutes each side until golden and reaches 165°F inside. Rest for 10 minutes before cutting into 1/4-inch pieces or pulling apart with forks. For already cooked chicken, pull it apart and season while it's still warm.
- Making Garlic Bread:
- Mix one stick of soft butter with 6 minced garlic cloves, 1 tablespoon Italian herbs, and 1/2 teaspoon salt. Spread lots on both sides of thick bread slices. Cook in big pan over medium heat for 3-4 minutes per side until dark golden and crunchy. For extra crunch, put under broiler for a minute.
- Creating The Spread (Version 2):
- Stir together 1/2 cup mayo with 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard, 1/2 teaspoon black pepper, 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder. Spread evenly inside toasted bread. This keeps your bread from getting soggy.
- Putting It Together:
- For Version 1: Put 1/2 cup mozzarella on one slice of garlic bread, add 1 cup seasoned chicken, 1/4 cup cheddar, and fresh herbs.
For Version 2: Spread chicken-mayo mix on bread, add cheese blend, top with second slice. - Last Cooking Step:
- Version 1: Broil open-faced 3-4 minutes until cheese completely melts.
Version 2: Cook in pan 4-5 minutes each side until golden with melted cheese, pressing lightly.
Pin it
Learning to make really good garlic bread changed my sandwiches from just okay to amazing. The trick is using butter at room temperature and really working that garlic paste into it.
Cheese Melting Tips:
Each cheese melts at different heat points. Start by adding mozzarella, put cheddar in halfway through, finish with Parmesan. This stops them from breaking apart and makes sure they melt just right.
Spread Ideas:
Make your own special spreads by mixing mayo with pesto, adding honey to mustard, or blending spicy pepper paste into butter. Remember to adjust your seasonings for each new mix.
Plan Ahead Ideas:
Make garlic butter up to a week early. Keep it wrapped well in the fridge. Cook and season chicken up to two days before. Warm it gently before putting your sandwich together.
Keeping It Fresh:
Store everything separately: Freeze garlic butter for up to 3 months, keep cooked chicken in fridge for 3 days, wrap cheese well for a week. Only put everything together right before eating.
Weekend Prep Tricks:
Make twice as much garlic butter and freeze in small amounts. Cook extra chicken, divide and refrigerate. Shred cheese ahead of time and store with parchment paper between layers.
Pin it
This sandwich is comfort food at its best. The mix of well-seasoned chicken, several melted cheeses, and crispy garlic bread creates a memorable meal that's both filling and easy to change up.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Would rotisserie chicken work here?
- Totally, it’s a time-saver and blends perfectly.
- → Got tips to avoid burned bread?
- Go low on the heat and keep an eye on the bread—it browns really fast.
- → Can I prep this meal in advance?
- Make the chicken filling ahead, but grill fresh when ready to eat.
- → Any good sides for this?
- Pair it up with chips, a salad, or some soup to round out the meal.
- → Is a panini press an option?
- Absolutely, cook in a hot press for 3–4 minutes until the cheese oozes.