Pin it
Sunday Pot Roast Sauce has become a family favorite in our home. There's something magical about how the pot roast breaks down into that flavorful tomato sauce, mixing perfectly with spicy sausage and al dente rigatoni. Whenever I cook this, wonderful smells drift through the house, and everyone rushes to grab a seat at the dinner table.
What's So Different About This
I'm amazed how this dish turns ordinary pot roast into something really special. The lengthy cooking time builds such amazing flavor layers while staying easy on your wallet. It's my number one pick when I've got lots of mouths to feed, and the extras taste even better the next day.
What You'll Need
- Chuck Roast: It's the best choice because it gets so soft and tasty.
- Italian Sausage: I shape these into small bite-sized meatballs.
- Fresh Vegetables: They build the foundation of taste.
- Herbs: Both dried and fresh for amazing smells.
- Good Tomatoes: San Marzano ones really do taste better.
- Tomato Paste: Gives that intense flavor boost.
- Red Wine: Adds that something extra special.
- Rigatoni: The sauce gets trapped inside these pasta tubes.
- Finishing Touches: Cream, butter and parmesan make everything taste fancy.
How To Make It
- Getting Ready
- I always season the beef chunks well and place them with my tiny sausage balls in my trusty Dutch oven.
- Creating Flavor
- All the chopped veggies and herbs go in next, filling the kitchen with amazing smells before cooking even starts.
- Slow Cook Time
- Four hours of low heat turns everything into an incredible sauce. I often make it a day early since it tastes even better after sitting overnight.
- Almost Done
- I pull apart the super tender pot roast back into the sauce while the pasta boils, and can't wait to dig in.
- Last Step
- Mixing everything with cream, butter and parmesan takes it to a whole new level.
Pin it
Think Ahead
What I really like about this sauce is how much it makes. We'll have it for dinner, then I store the rest in containers for the fridge or freezer to grab during busy weeknights. It's like doing a favor for my future self when I need a quick comfort meal.
Great Sidekicks
This goes so well with a simple green salad as the fresh veggies balance out the rich sauce. I always grab a loaf of crusty bread too because nobody can pass up soaking up all that amazing sauce from their plate.
Tools You Need
My Dutch oven works wonders for this dish, cooking everything so evenly. When life gets busy, I'll use my slow cooker instead which makes everything so much easier. Both ways turn out super tasty results.
Fresh Take On Old Favorites
This might not be exactly what my Italian grandma would make, but using pot roast brings its own kind of magic. I love how it creates such a fancy-tasting sauce without spending a ton of money. The meat just falls apart and blends into every spoonful, making everything taste so rich.
Why Pot Roast Works Best
Pot roast has become my favorite secret for this sauce. It changes completely during that long cooking time, breaking into soft strands that soak up all the flavors. It costs less than short ribs but the results are just as amazing.
Small Things That Make A Big Difference
I sometimes drop in a tiny star anise that adds such nice warmth. A good pour of red wine makes everything taste deeper, while fresh herbs brighten it all up. When it all comes together with that final bit of cream and parmesan, the sauce turns silky smooth.
Works For Every Occasion
We call it Sunday sauce but honestly, it fits any day of the week. Whether we're just having family dinner, celebrating a holiday, or hosting friends, it always gets compliments. Being able to make it ahead makes having people over so much easier.
Making Family Moments
This sauce means more to me than just food in our home. It brings everyone together, creating those special times where we talk and laugh over full plates. Each time I cook it, I remember why sharing good meals with the people I care about matters so much.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use a slow cooker?
- Absolutely, slow cook for 8-10 hours on low. Then transfer to the stove to mix in cream and finish with the pasta.
- → What does star anise do?
- It gives a hint of unique flavor to meat sauces. It's optional but common in some Italian-American households.
- → Is this good for meal prep?
- Yep! Make the sauce up to three days in advance. Heat it up and mix in cream and butter with fresh pasta when ready to serve.
- → What can I use instead of wine?
- Try beef broth along with a couple of tablespoons of balsamic vinegar as a swap.
- → Why use San Marzano tomatoes?
- They're naturally sweet and less tangy, which makes the sauce smooth. Regular crushed tomatoes will also work fine.