Pin it
Transform ordinary veggies into a mouthwatering sandwich experience with stacked pickled onions, smooth spreads, and garden-fresh produce. This creation highlights the genuine taste of each component, striking a perfect mix of crunch and softness that makes every mouthful unforgettable.
I stumbled upon this mix when I was trying to copy a sandwich from the café down the street. After lots of tries, this version beats the original and has become something we can't go without each week.
Picking Your Ingredients:
- Sourdough bread: Craft-style with tough outer crust and soft middle
- Cream cheese: Regular fat, not cold for easy spreading
- Greek yogurt: Drain if it's too runny
- Fresh herbs: Vibrant color, no brown spots or drooping
- Tomatoes: Mature but not squishy, old-fashioned types work best
- Avocados: Should give a bit when you gently squeeze them
- English cucumber: The slim kind with edible skin
- Red onions: New, solid with compact rings
- Sprouts: Crunchy, dry with no wetness
How To Make It:
- Simple Pickled Onions:
- Cut red onion into skinny rings about 1/8-inch thick. Throw in bowl with one lime's juice, 1 teaspoon salt, 1/2 teaspoon pepper. Wait 30 minutes, mix every 10 minutes. They'll get softer and turn bright pink.
- Herby Cheese Mix:
- Whip soft cream cheese until puffy, roughly 2 minutes. Slowly add Greek yogurt, beating until it's smooth. Stir in salt, pepper, onion powder, chopped fresh herbs. Let it sit 30 minutes so flavors blend together.
- Getting Bread Ready:
- Turn broiler on high. Butter one side of all bread slices completely. Put butter side up on baking sheet. Broil 2-3 minutes, turning the pan halfway, until golden but still soft inside.
- Prepping Tomatoes:
- Cut tomatoes into middle-thick rounds. Put them on paper towels, sprinkle both sides with lots of salt and pepper. Let them drain 10 minutes each side. Pat them dry before using.
- Making Avocado Spread:
- In a bowl, squash avocados how you like them. Add lemon juice and salt right away so they don't turn brown. For really smooth spread, blend in food processor.
- Putting It All Together:
- Start with toasty sides looking up. Spread cheese mix on one piece, avocado on the other. Stack tomatoes, cucumber, pickled onions on the cheese side. Add cheese if you want. Top with big handful of sprouts and spinach. Close sandwich, push down lightly.
Pin it
Every part has an important job. The pickled onions bring zing, the two spreads add richness, while the fresh veggies give you that nice crunch.
Prep-Ahead Options:
Make pickled onions up to 1 week early. Mix herb spread 3 days before. Cut veggies the morning you'll eat them.
Keeping Leftovers:
Store all parts in different containers. Put plastic wrap directly touching avocado spread to stop it turning brown.
What Goes Well With It:
Try with a thin soup when it's cold, fresh salad when it's hot. Cool cucumber soup works great any time of year.
Pin it
This sandwich turns basic veggies into a filling meal. The mix of zesty pickled onions, velvety spreads, and crisp vegetables creates waves of flavor that make even meat-lovers want to try this plant-based option.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can the creamy spread be prepped in advance?
- Definitely! Keep it in the fridge for up to 5 days.
- → What stops the bread from getting soggy?
- Toast the bread and add spreads on the inside layers, placing tomatoes over the cream spread.
- → Can I switch out sourdough bread?
- Yes, you can use any firm, toastable bread.
- → How long are pickled onions good for?
- Store them in the fridge, and they’ll stay fresh for about a week.
- → Can this sandwich be made vegan?
- Sure! Replace the cream cheese with a vegan alternative and skip the Havarti.