Crispy Cod Fish Sandwich

This top-notch Fish Sandwich turns fresh cod into a wonderfully crunchy, golden treat that's better than what you'd get eating out. The mix of well-seasoned fish, homemade tartar sauce, and soft brioche buns makes a sandwich that blends old-school comfort with fancy cooking tricks.

I've spent so many nights getting this just right in my kitchen, and I've found the real trick is double-coating the fish and watching the heat. These days my family asks for these instead of grabbing takeout fish.

Key Ingredients Breakdown

• Cod fillets: Go for chunky, solid pieces to get the best outcome
• Peanut oil: Handles high heat without burning for clean frying
• Old Bay Seasoning: Gives that perfect seafood kick
• Sparkling water: Creates an airy, crisp coating
• Fresh parsley: Adds freshness to your tartar sauce
• Dill pickles: Brings just the right amount of zip to the sauce
• Brioche buns: Offers that buttery softness against the crunchy fish

Easy-to-Follow Cooking Guide

Whipping Up Tartar Sauce:

Chop pickles and capers small. Stir mayo until it's smooth. Throw in everything bit by bit. Add salt and pepper how you like. Let it sit while you work on the fish.

Getting Oil Just Right:

Warm oil gradually so it doesn't get too hot. Keep it steady at 375°F. Use a solid, deep pot. Stick the thermometer on the side. Turn heat up or down as you go.

Getting Fish Ready:

Slice fish into same-size pieces. Dry them completely with paper towels. Add plenty of seasoning. Let them warm up a bit. Set up your flour and batter stations.

Coating Your Fish:

Roll in seasoned flour first. Tap off extra flour softly. Dunk fully in batter. Let extra batter drip away. Go straight to the hot oil.

Frying Like a Pro:

Slip fish into oil carefully. Don't put too many pieces in at once. Flip just one time while cooking. Watch the color and bubbling. Put on wire rack to drain.

Pin it

I started making this when I was trying to copy my grandpa's famous fish fry, and now it's turned into something I think he'd enjoy even more than his own.

Mastering The Oil Temp

After so many batches, I've learned that keeping your oil at the same heat is super important. I stick a candy thermometer to my pot and turn the heat up or down when needed. If it gets too hot, your coating turns brown while the fish stays raw; too cold and your fish soaks up way too much oil.

Prep-Ahead Tricks

The fish tastes best when fried right before eating, but I often get other stuff ready ahead of time. The tartar sauce actually gets better if you make it the night before. I also mix my dry coating ingredients and store them in separate containers, which saves tons of time when I'm ready to cook.

Picking The Perfect Bun

Your choice of bun really matters. After trying loads of different kinds, I've found that brioche hits the sweet spot between sturdiness and softness. Giving them a quick steam adds moisture while keeping them fluffy.

Switching Up Your Sauce

I've played around with lots of add-ins for the tartar sauce. Tiny chopped shallots give it extra tang, while fresh dill makes it more herby. If you like spicy food, try a pinch of cayenne or some finely diced jalapeños.

What To Serve With It

These sandwiches go great with classic sides. I love them with crunchy coleslaw, homemade fries, or a bright citrus salad. When friends come over, I set out different toppings and sauces so everyone can build their own perfect sandwich.

Dealing With Extras

Though they're best fresh, you can reheat leftover fish in a 350°F oven until it crisps up again. I always keep the sauce separate and make extra - it's awesome on other sandwiches too.

Pin it

These Fish Sandwiches have become my go-to comfort dish that everyone asks for at family dinners and weekend get-togethers. That mix of crunchy yet tender fish with tangy homemade sauce creates something really special that brings everyone around the table. Every time I make them, I remember that sometimes the easiest foods, made with care and attention, become the ones we treasure most.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How do I get super crispy fish?

You’ll want to coat the fish twice—first in flour, then in batter. Also, keep your oil at 375°F for the best crunch.

→ Can I make the tartar sauce in advance?

Totally! It keeps well for up to 3 days in the fridge, and it actually tastes better as the flavors blend together.

→ Why use sparkling water in the batter?

The bubbles make the batter airy and crispy when fried. Swap in light beer if that's what you’ve got.

→ Can frozen fish work for this?

Yep, just thaw it completely and make sure it’s dry before you coat it. That helps keep the crispiness on point.

→ What’s the deal with steaming buns?

It gives them that pillowy softness, melts the cheese perfectly, and makes the sandwich feel like a real treat.